American Financial Group (AFG) Options: Is Now the Time?

American Financial Group ('AFG') is an insurance holding company specializing in property and casualty insurance through its 'Great American Insurance Group'. The company focuses on specialized commercial products for businesses. AFG's core business involves providing a wide range of commercial coverages through 36 insurance businesses, allowing for local decision-making in underwriting, claims, and policy servicing. AFG targets specialty niches within the property and casualty market, including property and transportation, specialty casualty, and specialty financial sectors. AFG differentiates itself by allowing each of its businesses the autonomy to make decisions related to underwriting, claims and policy servicing. This entrepreneurial business model promotes agility, innovative product design, unique applications of pricing segmentation, as well as developing distribution strategies and building relationships in the markets served.

No relevant news was found for this stock today.

AFG's technical outlook is mildly bearish. The stock closed at $131.50, currently trading above its 50-day SMA of $138.39 and EMA 21 of $134.42. The recent price action shows a sharp reversal from the highs of $147.78 on October 3, declining to $130.38 on November 3, before a slight recovery. This indicates a strong downtrend. The MACD at -2.60 is negative, and MACDh is also negative, indicating bearish momentum. The RSI of 37.44 suggests the stock is approaching oversold conditions but still has room to decline. The STOCHk is at 16.84 and STOCHd is at 12.71, both low, indicating oversold conditions, which could lead to a short-term bounce. However, the ADX is at 34.07, indicating a strong trend, which, given the recent price action, is downward. The ROC_20 is at -11.74, indicating a significant decline in price over the past 20 days. The recent price action suggests continued weakness, with the price consistently failing to sustain rallies. While short-term oversold conditions might provide temporary relief, the overall trend and momentum indicators point to further potential downside in the coming 1–3 months.

American Financial Group's (AFG) MD&A presents a mixed picture. For the second quarter of 2025, 'net earnings' decreased to $174 million from $209 million in 2024, reflecting lower 'core net operating earnings' due to decreased underwriting profit and lower net investment income from alternative investments. 'Net earned premiums' increased by 4% to $1.647 billion. For the first six months of 2025, 'net cash provided by operating activities' was $533 million, a significant increase from $19 million in 2024; however, this was significantly impacted by changes in assets and liabilities of managed investment entities. Excluding the impact of the managed investment entities, 'net cash provided by operating activities' was $500 million in 2025 compared to $258 million in 2024. Management anticipates 'premium growth' and 'continued strong underwriting results', and expects the elevated interest rate environment to continue to positively impact investment income on fixed maturity investments in 2025. However, economic inflation, social inflation, and supply chain disruptions are noted as potential impacts on premium levels, loss cost trends, and investment returns. Overall, while premium growth is expected, profitability is under pressure due to lower investment income from alternative investments and higher loss and LAE ratios in some segments.

American Financial Group's (AFG) second quarter 2025 earnings call struck a moderately bullish tone, highlighting strong underwriting margins in their Specialty Property & Casualty businesses and increased net investment income. Carl Lindner III reported an annualized core operating return on equity of 15.5%, although tempered by alternative investment returns. Stephen Craig Lindner noted a 10% year-over-year increase in net investment income, excluding alternatives, due to higher interest rates, stating they're 'able to invest in fixed maturity securities at yields of approximately 5.75%'. While the annualized return on alternative investments decreased, they expect annual returns averaging 10% or better longer term. AFG returned over $100 million to shareholders through dividends and share repurchases. Gross and net written premiums were up 10% and 7%, respectively, but excluding the crop business, growth was 6% and 5%. Renewal pricing excluding workers' comp was up approximately 7%. Management expressed confidence in their ability to continue building long-term value, citing their experience navigating economic and insurance cycles, though they are closely monitoring social inflation exposed businesses.

AFG's financial performance presents a mixed but slightly positive outlook. Revenue has fluctuated, starting at $1,881M in Q1 2024, peaking at $2,369M in Q3 2024, and settling at $1,924M in Q2 2025, indicating some volatility but an overall stable trend. Gross profit ratio has varied significantly, ranging from 0.39 in Q3 2024 to 1 in Q4 2023, and is at 0 for the latest quarter, suggesting inconsistent profitability. Operating cash flow has been positive in most quarters, with a recent $342M in Q1 2025, demonstrating the company's ability to generate cash from operations, but data is missing for the most recent quarter. Total debt has remained relatively stable around $1.47B from Q1 2024 to Q1 2025. Overall, AFG exhibits revenue stability and positive cash flow, but inconsistent profitability and missing data for the most recent quarter warrant further investigation.

The company presents a moderately bullish investment profile based on its key metrics and financial ratios. Revenue has shown positive growth, indicating a healthy demand for its products or services. The gross margin has remained relatively stable, suggesting efficient cost management. The Return on Equity (ROE) indicates a solid return for shareholders. The Price-to-Earnings (P/E) ratio suggests the company is appropriately valued by the market. The debt-to-equity ratio has seen a decrease, showcasing the company's improved financial leverage. The current ratio signifies the company's strong ability to meet its short-term obligations. Overall, the company demonstrates a stable and growing business model with a healthy balance sheet, making it a moderately attractive investment for the next 6-12 months.